| Pos | Team/Player (seed) | Round 1 | Round 2 | Total |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | Hampden-Sydney | 301 | 301 | 602 +34 |
| T1 | Alex Simmons | +4 (F) | +2 (F) | 148 |
| T1 | Parker Smith | +4 (F) | +2 (F) | 148 |
| T5 | Austin Fockler | +6 (F) | +3 (F) | 151 |
| T18 | Aaron Persily | +5 (F) | +10 (F) | 157 |
| T24 | Jamie Agnew | +4 (F) | +13 (F) | 159 |
| Pos | Team/Player (seed) | Round 1 | Round 2 | Total |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 2 | Randolph-Macon | 313 | 298 | 611 +43 |
| T5 | Matt McDonagh | +9 (F) | E (F) | 151 |
| T9 | Chase Childers | +3 (F) | +7 (F) | 152 |
| T9 | Trey Razzetti | +7 (F) | +3 (F) | 152 |
| T18 | Peter Shaner | +10 (F) | +5 (F) | 157 |
| T28 | Kirby Struhar | +12 (F) | +6 (F) | 160 |
| 41 | Nick Stottlemyer | +15 (F) | +14 (F) | 171 |
| Pos | Team/Player (seed) | Round 1 | Round 2 | Total |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| T3 | Shenandoah | 311 | 305 | 616 +48 |
| T5 | Evan Cocke | +4 (F) | +5 (F) | 151 |
| 14 | Seth Crean | +6 (F) | +7 (F) | 155 |
| T15 | Brennan Lloyd | +6 (F) | +8 (F) | 156 |
| T24 | Brett Dubin | +11 (F) | +6 (F) | 159 |
| T31 | Michael Plath | +16 (F) | +3 (F) | 161 |
| 46 | Robert Fox | +14 (F) | +20 (F) | 176 |
| 48 | Ryan Parker | +21 (F) | +16 (F) | 179 |
| Pos | Team/Player (seed) | Round 1 | Round 2 | Total |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| T3 | Virginia Wesleyan | 303 | 313 | 616 +48 |
| T5 | Evan Cox | -1 (F) | +10 (F) | 151 |
| T12 | Hall Rupert | +5 (F) | +7 (F) | 154 |
| T12 | Peter Scrimgeour | +7 (F) | +5 (F) | 154 |
| T18 | Caleb Martin | +8 (F) | +7 (F) | 157 |
| T37 | Kevin Duffy | +11 (F) | +11 (F) | 164 |
| Pos | Team/Player (seed) | Round 1 | Round 2 | Total |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 5 | Bridgewater College | 309 | 309 | 618 +50 |
| T3 | Rhett Martin | +4 (F) | +4 (F) | 150 |
| T15 | Elijah Tackett | +12 (F) | +2 (F) | 156 |
| T22 | Ocean Armstrong | +5 (F) | +11 (F) | 158 |
| T24 | Dylan Burger | +12 (F) | +5 (F) | 159 |
| T24 | Luke Hill | +6 (F) | +11 (F) | 159 |
| T28 | E.J. Dillin | +10 (F) | +8 (F) | 160 |
| Pos | Team/Player (seed) | Round 1 | Round 2 | Total |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 6 | Roanoke College | 320 | 313 | 633 +65 |
| T9 | Kolton Cooper | +4 (F) | +6 (F) | 152 |
| T22 | William Brown | +10 (F) | +6 (F) | 158 |
| T28 | Alex Taylor | +12 (F) | +6 (F) | 160 |
| 36 | Andrew Butts | +10 (F) | +11 (F) | 163 |
| 40 | Colin Hancock | +18 (F) | +9 (F) | 169 |
| T42 | Daniel Johnson | +13 (F) | +18 (F) | 173 |
| T44 | Jack Prater | +17 (F) | +15 (F) | 174 |
| Pos | Team/Player (seed) | Round 1 | Round 2 | Total |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 7 | Shepherd | 314 | 325 | 639 +71 |
| T15 | Ryan Crabtree | +6 (F) | +8 (F) | 156 |
| T31 | Joe Burkinshaw | +6 (F) | +13 (F) | 161 |
| T33 | Brandon Dang | +9 (F) | +11 (F) | 162 |
| T33 | Erik Williams | +9 (F) | +11 (F) | 162 |
| 39 | Drew Call | +12 (F) | +11 (F) | 165 |
| Pos | Team/Player (seed) | Round 1 | Round 2 | Total |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 8 | Apprentice | 335 | 326 | 661 +93 |
| T3 | Perry Barber | +1 (F) | +7 (F) | 150 |
| T33 | Phillip Nelson | +15 (F) | +5 (F) | 162 |
| T42 | Toby Tapman | +18 (F) | +13 (F) | 173 |
| 47 | Will Hunter | +17 (F) | +18 (F) | 177 |
| 50 | Dylan Hogge | +22 (F) | +17 (F) | 181 |
| Pos | Team/Player (seed) | Round 1 | Round 2 | Total |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 9 | Eastern Mennonite | 340 | 334 | 674 +106 |
| T18 | Josh Alderfer | +11 (F) | +4 (F) | 157 |
| T37 | Andrew Alderfer | +7 (F) | +15 (F) | 164 |
| T44 | Lucas Miller | +21 (F) | +11 (F) | 174 |
| 49 | Travis Dull | +18 (F) | +20 (F) | 180 |
| 51 | Caleb Schlabach | +20 (F) | +21 (F) | 183 |