| Pos | Players | Team | Round | Total Score | To Par |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | |||||
| T1 | Matt Galloway | Brescia | 76 | 76 | +4 |
| T1 | Chad Carrico | Brescia | 76 | 76 | +4 |
| T1 | Wes Drees | Indiana U. - East | 76 | 76 | +4 |
| T4 | Zach Lemons | Asbury | 77 | 77 | +5 |
| T4 | Tyler Lyon | Brescia | 77 | 77 | +5 |
| 6 | Travis Fulkerson | Brescia | 78 | 78 | +6 |
| 7 | Dan Vessel | Brescia | 80 | 80 | +8 |
| T8 | Hubie Branstetter | Indiana U. - East | 82 | 82 | +10 |
| T8 | Daniel Gibbons | Asbury | 82 | 82 | +10 |
| T10 | Zack Palmer | Indiana U. - East | 83 | 83 | +11 |
| T10 | James Peruggia | Berea | 83 | 83 | +11 |
| 12 | Benjamin Wheatley | Asbury | 84 | 84 | +12 |
| 13 | Grant Collins | Brescia | 85 | 85 | +13 |
| T14 | Nick Ary | Indiana U. - East | 86 | 86 | +14 |
| T14 | Dakota Richardson | Indiana U. - East | 86 | 86 | +14 |
| 16 | Adam Ward | Asbury | 88 | 88 | +16 |
| 17 | Zach Burr | Asbury | 89 | 89 | +17 |
| 18 | Koby Rankin | Berea | 90 | 90 | +18 |
| 19 | Kaiser Dekam | Asbury | 92 | 92 | +20 |
| 20 | Hagan Southworth | Asbury | 93 | 93 | +21 |
| T21 | Derrick McNeeley | Indiana U. - East | 97 | 97 | +25 |
| T21 | Brandon Loomis | Indiana U. - East | 97 | 97 | +25 |
| 23 | Justin Carter | Indiana U. - East | 98 | 98 | +26 |
| 24 | Dan McPherson | Asbury | 99 | 99 | +27 |
| T25 | Eric Holmes | Berea | 101 | 101 | +29 |
| T25 | Lee Oaks | Indiana U. - East | 101 | 101 | +29 |
| 27 | Eric Hobson | Berea | 105 | 105 | +33 |
| 28 | A. Franklin McFadden | Asbury | 116 | 116 | +44 |