| Pos | Team/Player (seed) | Round 1 | Round 2 | Total |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | Charleston | 306 | 298 | 604 +28 |
| 1 | Alex Carrigan | +1 (F) | -3 (F) | 142 |
| 2 | Jamin Smith | +4 (F) | +2 (F) | 150 |
| T4 | Donald Weller | +7 (F) | +5 (F) | 156 |
| T10 | Mike Waggoner | +8 (F) | +6 (F) | 158 |
| T15 | James Leonard | +6 (F) | +10 (F) | 160 |
| T23 | Shane Chaplin | +11 (F) | +7 (F) | 162 |
| T38 | Eric Morris | +14 (F) | +15 (F) | 173 |
| Pos | Team/Player (seed) | Round 1 | Round 2 | Total |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 2 | West Liberty | 328 | 308 | 636 +60 |
| T10 | Matt Keding | +8 (F) | +6 (F) | 158 |
| T12 | Brandon Mills | +10 (F) | +5 (F) | 159 |
| T20 | Matt McGlaughlin | +9 (F) | +8 (F) | 161 |
| T23 | Joey Seabright | +14 (F) | +4 (F) | 162 |
| T23 | Tim Hausfeld | +13 (F) | +5 (F) | 162 |
| Pos | Team/Player (seed) | Round 1 | Round 2 | Total |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 3 | Shawnee State | 323 | 314 | 637 +61 |
| T7 | Bryan Spille | +7 (F) | +6 (F) | 157 |
| T15 | Cody Robbins | +9 (F) | +7 (F) | 160 |
| T15 | Isaiah Keller | +13 (F) | +3 (F) | 160 |
| 30 | R.D. Irwin | +10 (F) | +10 (F) | 164 |
| 36 | Ronald Dials | +9 (F) | +17 (F) | 170 |
| Pos | Team/Player (seed) | Round 1 | Round 2 | Total |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 4 | Mercyhurst | 321 | 317 | 638 +62 |
| T4 | Derek Fisher | +10 (F) | +2 (F) | 156 |
| T4 | Tyler Bidwell | +9 (F) | +3 (F) | 156 |
| T20 | Derek Elliott | +5 (F) | +12 (F) | 161 |
| T31 | Jake Pilarski | +9 (F) | +12 (F) | 165 |
| 37 | Matt Mahoney | +15 (F) | +13 (F) | 172 |
| 44 | Michael Wayner | +20 (F) | +17 (F) | 181 |
| Pos | Team/Player (seed) | Round 1 | Round 2 | Total |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 5 | Davis & Elkins | 323 | 319 | 642 +66 |
| T7 | Christopher Young | +5 (F) | +8 (F) | 157 |
| T12 | Alasdair Forsythe | +14 (F) | +1 (F) | 159 |
| T15 | Cory Dillinger | +10 (F) | +6 (F) | 160 |
| T23 | Colin Sutherland | +12 (F) | +6 (F) | 162 |
| T23 | Robert McCleneghen | +10 (F) | +8 (F) | 162 |
| T28 | David Shields | +10 (F) | +9 (F) | 163 |
| T38 | Samuel Oliver | +16 (F) | +13 (F) | 173 |
| T42 | Fred Roby | +17 (F) | +17 (F) | 178 |
| Pos | Team/Player (seed) | Round 1 | Round 2 | Total |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 6 | Shepherd | 325 | 319 | 644 +68 |
| 3 | Cameron Beckner | +6 (F) | +5 (F) | 155 |
| T15 | Jeremy Thompson | +10 (F) | +6 (F) | 160 |
| T28 | Aaron Stenta | +9 (F) | +10 (F) | 163 |
| T33 | Chris Gilkey | +12 (F) | +10 (F) | 166 |
| T40 | Jon Agee | +16 (F) | +14 (F) | 174 |
| Pos | Team/Player (seed) | Round 1 | Round 2 | Total |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 7 | West Virginia Wesleyan | 340 | 313 | 653 +77 |
| T12 | Mike Gervais | +8 (F) | +7 (F) | 159 |
| T20 | Jonathan Lodge | +15 (F) | +2 (F) | 161 |
| T31 | Mark Johnson | +12 (F) | +9 (F) | 165 |
| 35 | Matt Sisson | +17 (F) | +7 (F) | 168 |
| T42 | Ryan Michael | +21 (F) | +13 (F) | 178 |
| Pos | Team/Player (seed) | Round 1 | Round 2 | Total |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 8 | Glenville State | 339 | 341 | 680 +104 |
| T7 | Bryson Karp | +6 (F) | +7 (F) | 157 |
| T33 | Tom Meeks | +9 (F) | +13 (F) | 166 |
| T40 | Tyler Mossor | +15 (F) | +15 (F) | 174 |
| T45 | Joe Evans | +21 (F) | +20 (F) | 185 |
| T45 | Trae Sprague | +23 (F) | +18 (F) | 185 |
| 47 | Brandon Dolan | +27 (F) | +22 (F) | 193 |