| Pos | Team/Player (seed) | Round 1 | Round 2 | Total |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | Wittenberg | 307 | 285 | 592 +16 |
| 1 | Jordan Millice | +2 (F) | -4 (F) | 142 |
| T4 | Craig Osterbrock | +9 (F) | -2 (F) | 151 |
| T6 | Ben Smith | +5 (F) | +3 (F) | 152 |
| T6 | Bleu George | +8 (F) | E (F) | 152 |
| T6 | Ricky Boerner | +4 (F) | +4 (F) | 152 |
| T10 | Bradley Shepherd | +6 (F) | +3 (F) | 153 |
| T10 | Jonny Price | +3 (F) | +6 (F) | 153 |
| T16 | Steve Nevius | +6 (F) | +6 (F) | 156 |
| T25 | Lane Craig | +9 (F) | +7 (F) | 160 |
| T31 | Nick Hoch | +13 (F) | +6 (F) | 163 |
| Pos | Team/Player (seed) | Round 1 | Round 2 | Total |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 2 | Ohio Wesleyan | 312 | 296 | 608 +32 |
| 2 | Jesse Chiero | +6 (F) | -3 (F) | 147 |
| 3 | Jordan Benner | +6 (F) | E (F) | 150 |
| T18 | Mark Fischer | +5 (F) | +8 (F) | 157 |
| T21 | Nate Fridley | +7 (F) | +7 (F) | 158 |
| T21 | Thomas Fox | +10 (F) | +4 (F) | 158 |
| Pos | Team/Player (seed) | Round 1 | Round 2 | Total |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 3 | Wittenberg | 310 | 303 | 613 +37 |
| T4 | Mike Flickinger | +1 (F) | +6 (F) | 151 |
| T6 | Matthew Donahoe | +7 (F) | +1 (F) | 152 |
| T13 | Kevin Caja | +7 (F) | +4 (F) | 155 |
| T13 | Rob Hippert | +7 (F) | +4 (F) | 155 |
| 30 | Patrick Fritz | +10 (F) | +8 (F) | 162 |
| T31 | Collin Marozzi | +12 (F) | +7 (F) | 163 |
| T40 | Ryan Brindle | +21 (F) | +5 (F) | 170 |
| Pos | Team/Player (seed) | Round 1 | Round 2 | Total |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 4 | Wooster | 326 | 304 | 630 +54 |
| T13 | Blake Sword | +4 (F) | +7 (F) | 155 |
| T18 | Tim Sullivan | +12 (F) | +1 (F) | 157 |
| T23 | Greg Benckart | +9 (F) | +6 (F) | 159 |
| T23 | Michael Peters | +13 (F) | +2 (F) | 159 |
| T35 | Tim Faerber | +13 (F) | +10 (F) | 167 |
| Pos | Team/Player (seed) | Round 1 | Round 2 | Total |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 5 | Denison | 326 | 319 | 645 +69 |
| T16 | Connor Monaghan | +12 (F) | E (F) | 156 |
| T25 | Rob Colmery | +5 (F) | +11 (F) | 160 |
| 33 | Steven Geldart | +11 (F) | +9 (F) | 164 |
| 34 | Jeff Maier | +10 (F) | +11 (F) | 165 |
| Pos | Team/Player (seed) | Round 1 | Round 2 | Total |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 6 | Wabash | 326 | 321 | 647 +71 |
| T25 | Charlie Kelly | +11 (F) | +5 (F) | 160 |
| T25 | Sam Russell | +7 (F) | +9 (F) | 160 |
| 29 | Jordan Koch | +12 (F) | +5 (F) | 161 |
| 37 | Luke Moton | +10 (F) | +14 (F) | 168 |
| T38 | Andrew Palmer | +12 (F) | +13 (F) | 169 |
| T40 | Ben Foster | +14 (F) | +12 (F) | 170 |
| T43 | Kyle Nagdeman | +10 (F) | +17 (F) | 171 |
| T46 | Jake German | +19 (F) | +15 (F) | 178 |
| Pos | Team/Player (seed) | Round 1 | Round 2 | Total |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 7 | Kenyon | 337 | 330 | 667 +91 |
| T18 | Sam Hull | +5 (F) | +8 (F) | 157 |
| T38 | Jesse Boomsma-Gold | +16 (F) | +9 (F) | 169 |
| T40 | Jack Marra | +12 (F) | +14 (F) | 170 |
| T43 | Kodey Haddox | +16 (F) | +11 (F) | 171 |
| 48 | Mac Carroll | +17 (F) | +18 (F) | 179 |
| Pos | Team/Player (seed) | Round 1 | Round 2 | Total |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 8 | Hiram | 346 | 327 | 673 +97 |
| T10 | Andy Deehr | +8 (F) | +1 (F) | 153 |
| T35 | Bryan Todd | +18 (F) | +5 (F) | 167 |
| 45 | Bob Ritchie | +15 (F) | +16 (F) | 175 |
| T46 | Zach Baker | +17 (F) | +17 (F) | 178 |
| 53 | Michael Walton | +36 (F) | +30 (F) | 210 |
| Pos | Team/Player (seed) | Round 1 | Round 2 | Total |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 9 | Oberlin OC | 384 | 386 | 770 +194 |
| T49 | Andrew DeCarlo | +15 (F) | +26 (F) | 185 |
| T49 | Jake Panka | +22 (F) | +19 (F) | 185 |
| 51 | Ron Ruppard | +29 (F) | +23 (F) | 196 |
| 52 | Matt Richard | +30 (F) | +30 (F) | 204 |