| Pos | Team/Player (seed) | Round 1 | Round 2 | Total |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | Mercyhurst | 287 | 300 | 587 +11 |
| T1 | Derek Elliott | +1 (F) | -1 (F) | 144 |
| T1 | Derek Fisher | -1 (F) | +1 (F) | 144 |
| T1 | Matt Mahoney | -3 (F) | +3 (F) | 144 |
| 5 | Tyler Bidwell | -2 (F) | +5 (F) | 147 |
| 7 | Brian Corbitt | +4 (F) | +1 (F) | 149 |
| T8 | Colin Farabaugh | +5 (F) | +2 (F) | 151 |
| 13 | Jake Pilarski | +5 (F) | +4 (F) | 153 |
| T14 | Garrett Kimple | +6 (F) | +4 (F) | 154 |
| T14 | Robbie Trypus | +11 (F) | -1 (F) | 154 |
| T16 | Michael Sito | +6 (F) | +5 (F) | 155 |
| 18 | Michael Wayner | +7 (F) | +6 (F) | 157 |
| 20 | Patrick Jackson | +19 (F) | +9 (F) | 172 |
| Pos | Team/Player (seed) | Round 1 | Round 2 | Total |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 2 | Gannon | 295 | 299 | 594 +18 |
| 4 | Drew Deimel | -2 (F) | +3 (F) | 145 |
| 6 | Dom Lombardi | +2 (F) | +2 (F) | 148 |
| T8 | Corey Bowers | +5 (F) | +2 (F) | 151 |
| T8 | Derek Aicher | +7 (F) | E (F) | 151 |
| T11 | Jason Ramus | +2 (F) | +6 (F) | 152 |
| T11 | Matt Ferrie | +4 (F) | +4 (F) | 152 |
| T16 | Rob Hersch | +5 (F) | +6 (F) | 155 |
| 19 | Matt Barnes | +8 (F) | +10 (F) | 162 |